Showing posts with label Commodities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Commodities. Show all posts

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Bear Rally Chatter and Strategy Update









This market continues to favor traders and thrill seekers. I've talked about fading this market a number of times in the past few months, and, at the margin, that's what I've been doing. The basic rule has been simple: when my wife has had to talk me off the railing of our one-story deck, its time to buy, and when I start doing Schwarzenegger impressions, it's time to short. Recently, I've been doing Schwarzenegger impressions on the deck railing.

In mid-late November, I added positions in UWM and QLD as the market was again rolling over and the VIX (fear) index was once more spiking towards record levels. Since that time the number of market professionals looking for a bear market rally seems to have grown by the day. I've read quite a few of them just this week talking about a rally into early next year, even those who are very bearish. I'm a bit surprised by the timing of these calls considering that the market has already rallied 20% from its intraday low on November 21st. There's nothing like a good rally to bring out a bunch of predictions for...a rally. The lemmings that went over the cliff are climbing back up for the next jump.

Bear market rallies much greater than 20% aren't exactly common. That certainly doesn't mean that the current rebound can't go significantly higher. Recall, we had a 50% rally during the Great Depression, so there is precedent for very powerful upward moves during bear markets, but these types of moves are very unusual.

In fact, some of the strongest short-term market rallies tend to come during bear markets. It's easy to understand why: fear and greed. On the one hand, the market tends to get oversold in the short-term as fear of a job loss, insolvency, plague, and children who may never leave home grips the masses, and wholesale selling ensues. At the same time, investors who've lost a lot of money are eager to jump on any potential rally that may help them recoup some of their losses in order to help their child with the security deposit on their first apartment. And you never know, the next rally could be the beginning of the next bull market. Who wants to be the idiot who sold at the bottom and kept waiting forever for another chance to buy at those levels?

Back to the present. With a 20% rally already in hand, I have to believe that the easy money from this leg up has been made. That doesn't mean that the market can't go higher, but I'm back at what I call "an inflection point moment." I can't bring myself to add more general market exposure given the move we've already had (though I'm always scouting for individual company opportunities), yet the move up isn't so overdone that there's a clear signal to sell. Unfortunately, I'm just not smart/foolish/prescient/daffy enough to try and call market tops or bottoms, particularly those of a short-term nature. As a result, in this type of environment I tend to build marginal market long and short exposure as the strength or weakness of the market accelerates.

In keeping with that, I haven't yet sold the QLD or UWM positions, but they will be jettisoned should the market rally much further. In the meantime, I'm willing to give them a little more time as the market has finally been responding well to bad news. I have, however, recently added some modest new short exposure in the real estate area. This is partly due to the fact that this sector has had one of the smartest rebounds during this latest market rally. With the market up 20% from its lows, many real estate ETFs are up closer to 50%. This is a logical pool for bottom fishing given the degree of damage we've already seen, but I'm of the opinion that this sector will see further downside, particularly commercial real estate. The current short position is modest, and my intent is to increase the short side of the portfolio (and reduce longs) should the market rally continue.

This particular rally has been gratifying in that many of our core positions in the commodity, mining, industrial, and precious metal sectors have had nice moves. The recent decline in the U.S. dollar from ridiculous levels hasn't hurt. Many of the names/positions in these sectors are trading at very attractive valuation levels for those willing to look beyond the next few days. I've been gradually adding to this space during the downturn and expect to be very pleased with their performance over the next 5-10 years. In the near term, however, they won't be immune to the next sell-off in the market (at which time I'll be adding to them).

Disclosure: The Rubbernecker is long, short, and inflecting.


The Market Rubbernecker is affiliated with Aspera Financial, LLC, a registered investment advisor. Please read the disclaimer on the home page of the Market Rubbernecker site.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Q&A: What To Buy?

Jerry e-mailed to ask: "What stocks would you recommend buying during this downturn? XOM, COP, GE?"

This gives me a good opportunity to write a little about what I've been up to lately and what I'm thinking today. Of course, what I'm thinking today could differ significantly from what I'll be thinking tomorrow in this market.

As a quick reminder, I am not a day trader. Most of the positions I take are for the long-term though some are shorter-term opportunistic trades. In addition, I pursue a long/short strategy with most client portfolios. Part of the portfolio is long, and part is short. Where that split falls depends on the number of compelling short ideas I find as well as market and sector valuation (and the degree to which the government prevents me from shorting).

Obviously, the short portion of the portfolio has done well. I'd love to attribute that to my genius, but there isn't much you could have shorted recently and not done...it's because of my genius. Of course, a true genius would have held an even larger short position.

The long portfolio has been a mixed bag. It was designed to be defensive, and it had been up until this latest "baby and bath water" stage in which any semi-liquid security has been tossed overboard. The only things rising these days seem to be Treasury securities, gold, pessimism, some currencies, and the number of political ads on TV. The portion of our long portfolio that has done well is the exposure to cash, gold, the Japanese yen, and the Chinese yuan (renminbi). These positions have fortunately been the largest holdings in most portfolios. I wish they'd been larger still for they haven't offset the losses from the other long holdings.

With the decline in the market of the past 2 weeks, I've been gradually covering my short positions (SRS, QID, TWM). I have a few remaining (MS, BWLD, COF, AMZN, and HOG). I also still have some put options in some accounts on the QQQs. I anticipate closing most of these positions out in the near-term if the market doesn't spike higher (which would not be surprising). I'll probably keep the BWLD short a little longer as it hasn't come off its high too much, the valuation is still rich, cost (margin) pressures are building, and restaurant spending is a discretionary expenditure that is easy to rein in when times are tough. Buffalo wings are tasty, but I can put tabasco sauce on my tofu dogs and watch the game at home.

On the long side, I think the best long-term buys today are in some of the emerging markets and in the commodity space. Again, these should not be bought if you're looking to make a quick buck or if you're the obsessive type who monitors his investments every few minutes. They could easily fall significantly from here before finding a bottom, but if you are a true long-term investor, these are the areas I would focus on. Many of my long positions are in these two areas, and as I've indicated, I've been very gradually adding to them as they've come in, and I plan to roll the gains from the short positions into these areas.

As for emerging markets, I like China and Russia right now. You want exposure to China over the next couple of decades (probably longer) given their growth prospects and rising incomes, and you can get it today at a very reasonable price given the tremendous decline in their stock markets. There are some good, non-speculative, individual Chinese stocks to own, but most people would be better off with an ETF/fund (FXI, PGJ, GCH, CAF).

I also think Russia is looking interesting. That market has been blown apart from the "war" with Georgia and the decline of commodity prices on which Russia is highly dependent. Some degree of continuing conflict with its neighbors has already been discounted, and I believe the long-term outlook for many commodities is quite bullish. Russia is in a much better position than it was during its 1998 financial crisis. The Russians should have enough reserves to make it through the downturn as they are far less dependent on external financing than they were in 1998. Russian stocks are currently trading at some of the lowest multiples in the world right now - typically a good time to buy. One of the easiest ways to gain exposure to Russia is with RSX.

On the commodity front, I like many commodities long-term, but the supply-demand balance and time frame differs for each. In general, commodities are being knocked down of late due to declining demand from a contracting global economy as well as the general de-leveraging underway that is hitting all risky assets. These factors are currently overpowering the supply side of the equation. Longer-term, however, we need to watch what's going on with supply as well. Heading into this downturn, supply of many commodities was struggling to keep up with demand.

Currently, due to lower commodity prices, inability to access funding, declining demand, and higher costs, there is a steady flow of news detailing mine/project closures and postponements. In many cases, it's too expensive to start a new project even if you're able to scrape together the funding to do so. This will eventually lead to even lower supply. Once the global economy settles out and starts to grow again (and it will some day), I suspect it won't take long for investors to realize how serious the under-supply situation is. Some of the commodity names I'd recommend taking a look at include POT, MOS, DBA, DBB, SLV, GLD, NEM, GDX, TCK, RIO, BHP, AEM, PAAS, SSRI, NGD, and COW, but there are plenty of others interesting names as well these days.

The market cycles between financial assets and hard assets, although neither have been working over the past few months. I believe that commodities are still in a long-term bull trend and that the bull market will reassert itself at some point and run quite a bit further. My preference is to have "direct" exposure through ETFs as well as owning stocks that operate in the commodity space. I had hoped that the commodity-related stocks would have held up better, but in the current environment, everything liquid is being sold regardless of long-term prospects. The good news is that these stocks are offering amazing entry levels for the long-term investor, assuming we're not going back to living in caves and chasing our meals with clubs.

Let me turn to gold. I've been a big fan of gold for about 5 years now, and I think it makes sense for just about everyone to have some exposure here. Gold has performed well of late, and it's our largest single holding in most portfolios. I'm actually a little surprised that it hasn't done even better given the global financial stresses. The recent relative strength of the dollar is likely the key factor keeping gold from exploding, but the explosion in the money supply that's underway, the declining level of (already low) interest rates, the terrible shape of the U.S. government balance sheet, and the implosion of the financial system should be supportive, to put it mildly. At some point, I think there's a good chance of a gold mania.

As for gold vs. gold stocks, I own both. Currently, despite the price of gold hanging in there, gold stocks have been beaten up, and many are trading near their 52-week lows. If you have a longer-term horizon, you have a wonderful opportunity to put a basket of these stocks together and tuck it away. You could also buy GDX which would give you exposure to a basket of mining companies. In addition, owning actual gold coins somewhere offshore wouldn't be a terrible idea either.

As for XOM, COP, and GE specifically, my feeling is that there are better opportunities available. These names aren't likely to outperform the market when things eventually turn, and they haven't really provided much of a hiding place thus far. If you have a longer term time horizon I would focus more on companies that will be more leveraged to the upturn. If you like energy (I do long-term), take a look at PBR, CHK, APC, and XTO. Also take a look at the drillers, especially the offshore deepwater plays. It's probably a little early here still, but these will be strong winners again.

As for GE, anything with significant financial exposure is still off limits for the time being. I've had a net short position in financials (wish it had been bigger) during the decline. The problem has been that no one really knows what any financial company's balance sheet really looks like. If you don't know the quality of the balance sheet and you buy still buy the stock, you're simply gambling. I save my gambling for the poker table. And buying the larger banks because you think the government won't let them fail is a flawed strategy. True, Wells Fargo and Bank of America won't be allowed to fail, but as we've seen, you shouldn't expect the common shareholders to be bailed out.

One final note if you're picking individual stocks. Equity investors never worry much about the balance sheet or cash flow statement when times are good. Now that times are not so good, the balance sheet and cash flow statement are critical. If you're not going to look at 10-Qs and 10-Ks then you shouldn't be buying individual stocks. Companies with too much debt and/or too high a reliance on external financing are off limits. These are potential company killers. High debt with strong cash flow may be fine if the cash flow remains sufficient during the downturn.

UPDATE: I was a bit sidetracked from this post today due to the market. The market has now closed -- down another 675 points. Today's action isn't shocking given sentiment and the lifting of the short ban.

At this point, I have turned from bearish to neutral on the market overall. There is certainly more room for downside, but after a 40% decline in the market, normalized P/E is looking more reasonable, and I'm having a much easier time finding attractive long ideas. This market is either ready to implode or we're due for an explosive bear market rally.

At the end of the day, I closed out my short positions in MS, COF, HOG, and AMZN. Currently, the only short I have is BWLD. At these levels, I'll be putting some cash to work on the long side in some of the names mentioned earlier. Never a dull moment.

Disclosure: The Rubbernecker is long on long-term buying opportunities and short of shorts.

The Market Rubbernecker is affiliated with Aspera Financial, LLC, a registered investment advisor. Please read the disclaimer on the home page of the Market Rubbernecker site.

Saturday, July 26, 2008

Tis The Season

It's been a slow week posting-wise thanks to a busy week earnings season-wise. Earnings season is always a bit of a mind-numbing experience. Every day is met with a barrage of press releases, numerous analyst rating changes, and back-to-back conference calls with management explaining how their quarterly earnings would have been an all-time record if you just ignore the write-offs, higher commodity costs, lawsuits, accounting system transition issues, margin shortfall, higher tax rate, options expense, weather impact, goodwill amortization, order push-outs, and poor feng shui. It makes for some long days.

Of course, there are companies reporting good earnings -- mostly commodity-related companies, those benefiting from international growth and the weak dollar, and those that operate pawn shops. Those with the most excuses are the financials. The typical bank conference call this quarter can be summed up as follows:

We’re disappointed to report a record loss of 12 kajillion dollars, but our core business is performing strongly as you can see if you strip out the mark-to-market losses and the charge-offs.

Well, if I ignore my lack of buoyancy and my inability to breathe in the water, then I'm a world-class swimmer. They’re a bank! The purpose for their existence is to attract deposits/funds and invest the proceeds in securities and loans. It’s like Microsoft saying, “We had a great quarter aside from terrible software sales.”

Let’s be very clear. When a bank has to charge-off a good chunk of its loans, it's an admission that prior period earnings were overstated. Prior earnings benefited from these loans back when borrowers were actually making their payments and the bank wasn’t adding to reserves. These guys want the benefit of the overinflated prior period earnings but no penalty for the current period charge-offs. It would be genius if it weren't so ridiculous.

Despite some truly poor earnings in general from the financial sector this quarter, we did witness a very robust rally in the group. This wasn't terribly surprising. As I wrote on July 15th in my Trader VIX post,

...the VIX has had an uncanny ability to predict short-term rallies (lasting between 2 weeks to 3 months) in the S&P 500 (top chart) each time it has exceeded 30 in the past year. As the VIX has approached this level, I've been less inclined to initiate new short positions and more inclined to cover existing shorts. Note that the intraday high for the VIX today was 30.81.

It seems I wasn’t the only one watching the VIX. Almost as soon as the VIX crossed 30, the market made its most recent low and began its latest bounce. With financials having been sold-off so brutally over the prior 2 ½ months, it was no surprise that they benefited the most from the rally.

Also from the Trader VIX post,

In general, I'm expecting plenty of earnings misses and fairly restrained (to put it mildly) earnings guidance over the next month. But, with cash on the sidelines and a pervasive sense of gloom in the market, an earnings season short of cataclysmic may be just enough to spur the next bear market rally.

This also turned out to be the case. Prior to Thursday, the S&P 500 rallied more than 6% over a mere 6 trading days. Generally speaking, the earnings results from the financials were awful, but since they turned out to be less terrible than feared, the group enjoyed a powerful rally.

The other strong move of note this month has been the sell-off in practically every commodity and commodity-related company. I’ve been cautioning that this would happen at some point and that this is normal bull market activity. I had pared back exposure to the group and have been keeping some dry powder ready for just such a pullback.

In recent days, I’ve been gradually putting some of that dry powder back to work, adding to some energy, metals, and agriculture names. I anticipate adding further should investors continue to bail out. As for the financials, I've had no interest in chasing the latest rally. For now, I'm on the sidelines, but should the group rally further, I'll be looking to rebuild a short position in the sector.

My writing is likely to continue to be a little thin over the next couple of weeks since we're in the meat of earnings season. I'm not as effective or coherent a writer when I'm in an earnings release-induced state of catatonia.

Disclosure: The Rubbernecker is long commodities and caffeine and very short sleep.

Friday, July 18, 2008

Google and Gas

“When everyone dislikes something it should be examined. When everyone likes something it should be examined.” -- Confucius

One of the biggest surprises to me from the Google conference call was learning that Google employs a Chief Economist. Had I only been aware of this earlier, I would’ve shorted more shares. I’ve been on many hundreds of conference calls over the years, but I’m having trouble remembering any in which a Chief Economist was one of the presenters. This was often one of the few positive qualities of these calls. Whenever I'd find myself struggling to pay attention to the mindless reading of the press release by the CEO, I'd mutter to myself, "Well, at least I don't have to listen to an economist."

The fact that high-flying, vanquish-all-comers, paradigm-changing Google is the first that I can recall offering up an economist to the investment community seems a bit ironic. This is Google! Shouldn't we be hearing from the Chief Envisioneer of World Domination instead? Perhaps this will be one of those little things we’ll point to in a few years as evidence that the days of heady growth for Google were winding down.

I wrote a critical review of Google's first quarter earnings release back in April when the stock popped from $450 to $540 and all of the analysts were tripping over themselves to see who could capture the most headlines with the biggest price target increase. In my conclusion of that piece, I said that I'd be keeping an eye on the stock and possibly buying put options if the stock kept running.

I didn't buy the put, opting to short the stock instead as increased volatility made put buying a little too expensive. And, unfortunately, I didn't short the stock as it neared $600. The short was initiated last week in the mid-$540s. Even though the stock had already pulled back 10% from its recent high, It was just too tempting. GOOG had held up better than the market during this latest downturn, and it seemed that the entirety of the sell-side community and press were bullish and expecting yet another outstanding googlerific quarter. On top of this, the concerns I shared from last quarter hadn't diminished, and the economy had deteriorated further. It was an appetizing recipe for an earnings disappointment.


Of course, the sell-side was out after the call defending their buy recommendations on Google. I haven't seen one downgrade. AmTech Research is keeping its "Buy" rating but lowering its target from $750 to $725. Cantor keeps their "Buy" and lowers their target from $750 to $675. Kaufman Bros. maintains their "Buy" and lowers their target from $680 to a nice round $657. $657? 57? 7? I mean, c'mon. You feel that confident in your $657 target that you didn't want to round it down 0.304414% to a nice even $655? How can anyone take this supposed precision seriously given the multitude of highly variable factors that go into that target in the first place? Asinine.

The average target price of these three analysts/lemmings implies 40% upside in the stock. The last downgrade I see is a beaut. Jefferies downgraded GOOG from a "Buy" to a "Hold" on February 1, 2008, the very day the company issued disappointing earnings and the stock opened 36 points lower. The downgrade also came one month AFTER the stock fell from a high of over $700 to about $520. See the station? See the train? No? That's because it's already gone. Over the following 5-6 weeks the stock traded as low as $412. When did the analyst upgrade the stock? He waited until April 18th, the day Google reported their "strong" first quarter earnings and the stock opened at $535. It would be difficult to try and time this stock worse.

So what about this quarter's earnings release? As you know by now, EPS came in a bit light, even with the benefit of currency and a nice low tax rate. Unlike the denials in the last conference call, the company finally owned up to being impacted by the slowing economy. They also admitted that the U.K. business was now large enough that seasonality was becoming evident. Paid click growth actually declined sequentially, and revenue growth (one of the concerns I highlighted last quarter) continued to slow.


Growth is clearly the overriding issue here. Huge early market share gains that could mask seasonality and economic weakness are quickly evaporating, which shouldn't be a huge surprise given the scale of GOOG. The question then turns to what the company is worth and what is an attractive stock price. With the stock now trading at about 20x 2009 estimated EPS, I don't find the stock particularly compelling, but I also no longer view it as ridiculously overvalued. Because of this, I covered the short today (Friday). I'll be watching the stock with an open mind from here and would be inclined to fade any substantial move in either direction.

As for the "Gas" part of this piece, since exiting my natural gas position on June 20th I've been patiently sitting on my hands waiting for another crack at it. With this sector and the price of natural gas now down over 20% from their recent highs, my patience has worn thin. I dipped my toe back in on Thursday afternoon, buying one of my favored domestic natural gas E&P names. As usual, the plan is to pump up the position should investors continue to bail out of the sector.

Disclosure: The Rubbernecker is happy to once again have a little gas.

Saturday, July 12, 2008

A Solution to Spiraling Food Prices

"You can't always get what you want. But if you try sometimes, you might find, you get what you need." Rolling Stones



When it comes to commodities, it all boils down to Economics 101. Barring government intervention (not usually a safe assumption), prices will tend to rise when demand exceeds supply, and vice versa. Most commodities have been in a bull market the past few years as demand has been greater than supply, and these bull markets can last for some time. But make no mistake, just like any random federally-chartered, shareholder-owned, implicitly federally-backed, government sponsored housing enterprise, their run will eventually come to an end.

Ironically, one of the signals of the impending peak will likely be that "everyone" starts spouting off that "it's different this time". We're seeing some early signs of that for certain commodities already, but we're really looking for some of that good old-fashioned Greenspanian irrational exuberance. More specifically, I'll be keeping an eye out for the following signs of the top:
  • The cover of Time Magazine or the Economist will show a 22-year old hedge fund manager hugging a gas pump.
  • MTV will roll out a new show called "Pimp My Deere" which will take run-down tractors and combines and fit them with waterproof woofers, satellite internet access, 19-inch monitors for day trading futures, chrome rims, custom flame paint jobs, and solar-powered espresso machines.
  • My plumber will excitedly tell me how he just bought his first soybean meal futures contract and shorted the S&P 500.
  • My clients will push me to buy even more gold because it has been going up for so long and their cousin's neighbor told them it was a no-brainer.
  • My vegetarian wife will want to quit her interior decorating business to trade feeder cattle futures.
  • No one will really care what I think about commodities, because they will have "figured it out."
This is what happens during bubbles. Everyone becomes an expert. I still recall how, prior to the dot-com bubble, I was sought out at parties for investment ideas and my opinion about the market (though I'd like to think it was my overpowering charm and machismo). However, as the Nasdaq accelerated and peaked, interest in my opinion quickly disappeared. Actually, I'd go to a party and once people learned that I was a portfolio manager, they'd start pitching me internet stocks! When they learned that I wasn't a tech bull, they'd look at me with a hint of derision and pity, and the conversation would abruptly end. 10 minutes of self-affirmation in the guest bathroom, and I'd be back at the punch bowl telling people I was a day laborer so they'd talk to me.

Once everyone believes in the commodity bull and has invested in it, the upside obviously becomes much more limited. Of course, we don't only focus on crowd sentiment. We have to keep an eye on supply and demand. All else equal, high commodity prices eventually spur the development of new supply. High prices may also result in demand destruction as consumers/purchasers alter their spending patterns and search for substitutes. As a recent example, driving miles in the U.S. have fallen fairly significantly in the U.S. due to high gas prices.

Yesterday, the Economist offered up a tasty little morsel of an article dealing with the issue of demand destruction and substitution as it relates to food. The following are some excerpts from their piece entitled, "Let Them Eat Bugs."
What with rising fertiliser prices, increasing concerns about deforestation and unreliable rains brought on by climate change, how will we find new sources of nourishment?

Scientists at the National Autonomous University of Mexico have an answer: entomophagy, or dining on insects. They claim the practice is common in some 113 countries. Better yet, bugs provide more nutrients than beef or fish, gram for gram.

Meat provides just under one fifth of the energy and one third of the protein humans consume. But its production uses up a hugely disproportionate share of agricultural resources. Feed crops gobble up some 70% of agricultural land, while a quarter of the world’s land is devoted to grazing. Brazil’s burgeoning livestock industry is responsible for huge swathes of deforestation in the Amazon.

For one thing, the habit could help to protect crops. Some 30 years ago the Thai government, struggling to contain a plague of locusts with pesticides, began encouraging its citizens to collect and eat the insects. Officials even distributed recipes for cooking them. Locusts were not commonly eaten at the time, but they have since become popular. Today some farmers plant corn just to attract them. Stir-frying other menaces could help reduce the use of pesticides.

Those looking for a reliable source of protein might prefer to farm them. Protein makes up a high proportion of most insects’ weight. That makes them much more efficient at converting feed to protein than livestock. For example, a cow yields only 10lb (4.5kg) of beef for every 100lb of feed it eats, whereas the same amount of feed would produce tens times as much cricket.

Environmentally and nutritionally, insects are more appealing than meat: you get more for less. But persuading flesh-loving, ento-phobic westerners of this is going to be tricky. “We’re not going to convince Europeans and Americans to go out in big numbers and start eating insects,” Mr Durst concedes. The trick might be to slip them into the food chain on the quiet. Supplements composed of insect protein could be added to processed food and perhaps also to animal feed. That might help to make meat a little more environmentally palatable.
How's that for an Inconvenient Truth? Now, I'm not quite ready to sell my agriculture positions because of a looming surge of interest in locust burgers and potato bug salad. As a "trap-and-release" vegetarian, I'm likely to keep paying up for my soy products, but I can envision this new food source being popular with the 6-8 year old male demographic.

The key point is that we're probably somewhere in the middle innings of the commodity bull market, and although this bull could run for many more years, we need to keep a close eye out for evidence of new or rising supply and falling demand. Also, it's important to remember that the supply/demand picture for each commodity differs. The ability to quickly ramp supply differs. The cost of increasing supply differs. The ability to substitute differs. And, the willingness of people to eat bugs differs.

Disclosure: The Rubbernecker is long many commodities and short the food preferences of the 6-8 year old male demographic.

Saturday, May 3, 2008

An Entry From My Dromediary About POT and MOS

Commodities are clearly in the midst of a bull market. On a daily basis, we're being deluged with stories of rising gasoline prices, rice shortages, soaring demand for steel, etc. These high prices will certainly encourage the development of new supply in time. A nearer-term impact will be product substitution when feasible. If steak costs too much, buy chicken instead. If the price of rice is too high, substitute potato. If the cost of cocoa soars.....bad example. I'm still buying cocoa.

The following example of the substitution effect is from a recent article in the Financial Times. It has me seriously thinking of swapping my Accord for some sled dogs.

Farmers in the Indian state of Rajasthan are rediscovering the humble camel.

As the cost of running gas-guzzling tractors soars, even-toed ungulates are making a comeback, raising hopes that a fall in the population of the desert state’s signature animal can be reversed.

“It’s excellent for the camel population if the price of oil continues to go up because demand for camels will also go up,” says Ilse Köhler-Rollefson of the League for Pastoral Peoples and Endogenous Livestock Development. “Two years ago, a camel cost little more than a goat, which is nothing. The price has since trebled.”

The shift comes not a moment too soon for a national camel population that has fallen more than 50 per cent over the past decade, to about 450,000, according to government figures.

Market prices for these “ships of the desert”, which crashed with the growing affordability of motorised transport, are rising again as oil prices soar.

A sturdy male with a life expectancy of 60-80 years now fetches up to Rs40,000 ($973), compared to Rs5,000-Rs10,000 three years ago, according to Hanuwant Singh of the Lokhit Pashu-Palak Sansthan, a non-profit welfare organisation for livestock keepers. Entry-level tractors cost around $4,000.

As far as I know, there are no camel futures or ETFs, and I'm not suggesting you mail order a caravan of camels in the hope of reselling them for a tidy profit . Remember, you have to pay for shipping, feed them, and pick up after them. And then there's the spitting. Oh, the spitting!

The point, as usual with commodities, is that the end of the bull for any particular commodity will eventually come from falling demand, rising supply, or both (2 years spent getting an MBA for that insight). Product substitution is just one factor to keep an eye on. In the short-term, we're more likely to see it in the agriculture space than metals or energy, given their relative fungibility.

If you really know what you're doing and have a great handle on the fundamentals of different agricultural commodities then you can do very well in the futures market. This can also be a bit dangerous since not all crops move together and significant retracements should be expected.

My preferred way to gain exposure to the agriculture space has been through the fertilizer space, which has been enjoying and is likely to sustain favorable supply/demand fundamentals. With these firms, we don't have to worry too much about product substitution. Yes. Different crops have different fertilizer needs, but there's nothing in the immediate future likely to totally replace potash and nitrogen use.

This past week, I added to positions in Potash (POT) and Mosaic (MOS). Both of these stocks have pulled back roughly 15% in the past 10 days as investors began rotating out of the the commodity space in general. I believe these names (and AGU which I also own) are in a secular (rather than cyclical) bull market. Their earnings growth is terrific, their valuation looking into 2009 is attractive (low double-digit P/E for both), and they're generating a ton of free cash.

Key fertilizer supply is constrained and demand continues to grow given the rising populations and dietary demands of the developing world. The rising prices of agricultural commodities is increasing the demand for fertilizers in order to maximize crop yield and also increasing the ability of farmers to pay higher fertilizer costs. These are the types of names that institutions will want to own given their fundamentals, valuation, and stock performance. This share demand support is likely to limit downside barring a significant adverse change in fertilizer supply or demand.

My strategy with these names has been to lighten as they've gone parabolic or become too large a portion of the portfolio and to add when we get these 10-20% pullbacks. A core position has been maintained regardless of price action. Should the stocks continue to fall in the coming weeks, I fully expect to keep adding.

The author currently has no camel position.

Sunday, April 27, 2008

Ricing Frustrations: Follow-Up



The pace of the increase in the price of rice has gone from a wok to a run since last fall. Brazil, Egypt, Vietnam, Cambodia, and Egypt have placed restrictions on rice exports. Other countries such as China are imposing punitive tariffs, and still others have begun stockpiling. Even Sam's Club and Costco have started limiting rice purchases. If the cost of water wasn't so expensive in my town, I'd be turning my yard into a paddy field.

It's difficult to really know the extent of the rice shortage because of the stockpiling and hoarding that is occurring at the country and individual level. These actions serve to drive up the near-term demand for rice which leads to higher prices which leads to more hoarding.....


As I wrote in the original "
Ricing Frustrations" post:

Clearly, demand has been outstripping supply (as with many commodities). The key will be to look for the inflection point. There's a huge incentive these days (where prices are not constrained) to put even marginal land back into farm service. Pests, disease, and weather are always wild-cards, but the incentive to plant is there.

From an article in today's The Times of India:

Thailand's Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej promised Sunday that the kingdom would not cut rice exports, as soaring prices of Asia's staple grain continued to fuel concerns of a shortage.
Samak said in his weekly television address to the nation that there was plenty of rice in Thailand, the world's biggest exporter.
"Thailand will not announce a ban on rice exports. It would destroy our reputation," he said.
He explained that farmers were now planting five crops in two years -- up from the traditional two crops per year -- to ensure they met demand.

This is precisely the type of action we should expect to see with rice prices hitting record levels. More land will be put to agricultural use, and crops will be planted more frequently (which could have longer-term soil productivity implications).

Rice is a staple of nearly 3 billion people. Governments may tinker with education, health care, business incentives, and tax policy, but food is the most basic human need. If you can't feed your people you won't remain in power, so there's a strong incentive for governments to try and address this issue. We can expect to see more and continued export limits, price caps, farming incentives, rationing, tariffs, land conversion programs, etc. Some of these policies (such as price caps and higher export taxes) will impede the development of new supply but others (such as land conversion and farming incentives) will encourage development. Some countries will get it wrong, and others will get it right.

Ultimately,
the natural forces of supply and demand will correct this rice crisis. We'll see new supply coming from countries which aren't limiting exports or prices. Hoarding will diminish. People will substitute Smores for Rice Krispy treats. We'll see more bubble blowing than rice throwing at weddings.

From an investment perspective, no one knows how high rice prices will ultimately go, but you can be sure that market forces are currently unfolding and sowing the seeds of a future sharp correction in the price of rice.


Thursday, April 24, 2008

Agriculture Stocks - Pulling Back as Expected

It looks like we're getting the pullback I was expecting in the agriculture/fertilizer companies (see last week's post "This Sector is Full of Sh*t"). In the past couple of days, Potash (POT), Agrium (AGU), and Monsanto (MON) have pulled back about 10%, and Mosaic has pulled back about 15%. As suggested, I did modestly reduce exposure to these names and was lucky enough to do so pretty close to their recent highs.

Today, Potash reported outstanding results. The fundamentals of this industry remain terrific with companies enjoying strong pricing power and cash generation. Given the pullback in the sector, today I started adding back the position I just sold a few days ago with purchases of POT and MOS. Should the group continue to retrace (certainly possible), I'll likely continue to add to these names opportunistically.

Thursday, April 17, 2008

This Sector is Full of Sh*t

Monsanto




Potash


Agrium


Mosaic


The fertilizer companies have been on a tear for a while now but have recently started going parabolic. This is largely due to the increasing amount of news and attention being paid to the global food crisis. Just today, Reuters reports:

China slapped massive tariffs on fertilizer exports on Thursday in a bid to control rapidly rising domestic agricultural costs and inflation, and above all to ensure it grows enough grain to feed its 1.3 billion people.

Beijing's 100 percent-plus tariffs on some fertilizer exports should temper domestic costs but may drive up prices in world markets that depend on China's supplies, the latest in a series of commodities-related protectionist moves around the world that risk fueling rather than cooling global food costs.

They're exactly right. A number of countries have started imposing export restrictions on certain types of food and now fertilizer. These types of restrictions are often accompanied by price caps, tariffs, and hoarding. Hoarding certainly will lead to short-term price rises. More importantly, to the extent that producers are restricted from selling their food and fertilizer at prevailing world prices they are also less incented and financially able to increase their production.

These agriculture/fertilizer stocks have been some of our best performers (AGU, POT, MOS). The longer-term thesis is still attractive, but the stocks are likely a bit ahead of themselves near-term. These are some of our larger positions given their appreciation. In this situation, we're likely to pare our position very modestly, taking some of the recent gains off the table. We plan to keep a sizable position in this space since the thesis is still attractive, and we would look to add should the stocks pull back.



Friday, April 11, 2008

Ricing Frustrations

To think, I was actually a little tweaked that the cost of my Bran Flakes was 30 cents higher on my last shopping trip.

This link offers a number of brief videos from the BBC on the global rice shortage. According to the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO), 37 countries are facing a food crisis, and food riots have broken out in several African countries, Indonesia, the Philippines and Haiti.

The beauty of investing in commodities is that there are relatively few variables that need to be monitored and no company-specific factors to worry about. Price boils down to supply and demand. Currently, with many agricultural commodities we are seeing demand increase due to increasing populations, a rising middle class in parts of the the developing world, and new demand for ethanol. Supply hasn't kept pace.

When we look at the US Department of Agriculture's figures for rice, we find that this supply-demand imbalance has led to a decline in global rice stocks from a peak of 130 million tonnes in 2000-2001 to 72 million tonnes in 2007-2008, the lowest level since 1983-84. According to the same report, nearly half of the world's 6.6 billion people are dependent on rice and are already eating more than is harvested yearly. The price of rice on the Chicago Board of Trade has doubled in the past year.

In response, governments are curbing rice exports in an attempt to keep prices down and bolster local supply. To the extent that they're instituting price controls they're taking away incentive for farmers to expand planting, and the limiting of exports is leading to crises in import-dependent countries like the Philippines. Consumers are hoarding rice as well, furthering the supply crisis.

Clearly, demand has been outstripping supply (as with many commodities). The key will be to look for the inflection point. There's a huge incentive these days (where prices are not constrained) to put even marginal land back into farm service. Pests, disease, and weather are always wild-cards, but the incentive to plant is there. The question is whether this will result in a narrowing of the supply-demand gap.

The fertilizer companies continue to be well-positioned and should be a key beneficiary again this year. I continue to like this space, but I'll be watching the supply figures carefully.

In the meantime, I'll be expanding my pantry and hoarding my Bran Flakes.